Showing posts with label bfc keynote. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bfc keynote. Show all posts

08 December 2011

How did I get here?

Do you ever take a look around you, and ask yourself: “Now, how did I get here?” I found myself doing that a lot during the last week of October. The question wasn’t the kind of thing that wakes you in the middle of the night in a cold sweat (though in the weeks leading up to October 25, there were plenty of those). Rather, it was a query of wonder. As I stood in the Blackfriars Playhouse October 25-30, I felt as though I had super-glued rose-colored glasses to the bridge of my nose and couldn't shake that amazing feeling that comes when one is surrounded (at home, no less) by dear friends (new and old), excellent conversation, amazing scholarship, and the joy of the work of two years coming to fruition in a beautiful way.

Ah, the Blackfriars Conference 2011.

My parents have a difficult time understanding me when I say “I won’t be really available for a few weeks, the conference is coming up.” What, exactly, could be keeping me so busy? To be fair, when we were separated by only 90 miles, as opposed to the 1300+ that divide us now, my life was pretty hectic. In my occupation as a high school Theatre teacher, teaching five classes daily, producing six shows a year, with set-building, costume construction, tech rehearsals, I was never as consumed as I am when Conference time rolls around in the odd-numbered year. It’s different, a different kind of busy – an all-consuming, all-anticipating, all-energizing, and yes, all-exhausting kind of feeling that builds for 24 months and culminates in a week of shared excitement, with faces both new and familiar. And the joy of overhearing as the answer to “How did you get here?” not “Bus, train, car,” but “I heard about it from...” or the even more gratifying “I come every time, wouldn’t miss it.”

My first conference was at its third incarnation in 2005, when I was in my first year in the Masters Program at MBC. Two months into the program, and I found myself in the same room with the authors of my textbooks and all of the articles I was looking up in Shakespeare Quarterly.

Why, hi there, Russ MacDonald (*RUSS MACDONALD?!?!?*). Oh, you’re from Texas, too? How nice to meet you!

Well, hello Tiffany Stern (*TIFFANY STERN!!!!*) I love that skirt.

And over there is Stephen Booth, George Walton Williams, Roz Knutson, Leslie Thomson, Alan Dessen. And some friends no longer with us, Bernice Kliman, Arnie Preussner, and Barbara Palmer, whose absence we have felt with sorrow since our last parting.

I knew, in that moment at my first Early Arrivers’ party, that this place was special. What other grad program gives its students the opportunity to network on their home turf? In this case, the turf of the Blackfriars playhouse, always a space of generosity and intimacy and, for one week in October on odd-numbered years, a space of enviable scholarship and flourishing ideas. How was I lucky enough to get here?

My previous conference experiences were all in my undergrad discipline, Theatre Arts. Those conferences featured more workshops than papers, more seminars than presentations, more off-the-cuff speaking than formal delivery. It was a shock to my system to see people reading from a lectern on the stage. But then, the ASC actors arrived. Their contributions linked the two worlds as no other glue or bridge could. They are proof that seeing is the quickest path to believing, whether one needs to be shown a character or helped to understand a presenter’s thesis. In the years since my first conference, it has been my privilege to work with those talented actors to improve interactions between presenters and their actors, to improve communication, to improve the general affect of the conference. We’ve come a long way, and though I know we still have some way to go toward a perfect system, the coming-together of actors and scholars in the way the Blackfriars Conference encourages makes me exclaim: how did I get here and how long can I stay?

In 2007, 2009, and again in 2011, the Conference gave me the opportunity to work along side my mentor, and, I am glad to say, my friend, Ralph Alan Cohen. When I took over from Sarah Pharis (aka Sarah #1) in 2007, I had big shoes to fill. Sarah’s organizational structure -- her daily work flow chart is still the basis for everything that happens behind the scenes -- made it possible for me to step in and to help Ralph to achieve his goals: good papers, good friends, good food, good times. It’s not as easy as it sounds. This year, I began to think of it as akin to planning a 6 day party for 250 of my dearest friends. Each hour of each of the 16 hour days just needs to be scheduled with events, food, drink, and plays. I’d just need to contact each of the 100+ presenters, the 50 grad students, the 15 actors, the 5 caterers, and the 5 venues to give them individual instructions for each minute of that time, get the invites and the publicity out, and then make sure everyone feels pampered and loved while they are here. Not so hard. It’s not, really.

Not this year, anyway. For the first time since my 2005 conference (when I was merely a volunteer), I had a full team in place and on board so early with planning and strategizing, that I actually got to watch my friends, both presenters and actors, in every session, and I watched the rest of my friends in the audience enjoying every minute.

How did I get here? Well, for that, I have loads of people to thank. Ralph, for trusting, the ASC actors and artistic staff for being so generous and sharing their talents in the highlight event of each day, Cass, Ben, Christina, Asae, Kim, Anne, bear wrangler Brian, Clara, Paul (Menzer and Rycik), the entire admin staff at ASC, the wonderful box office staff, the artistic staff and actors for making each session and evening performance memorable, the MBC students who exceeded their colleagues at past conferences in both volunteering and contribution of scholarship. They made it look (and feel) easy, and I am tremendously grateful.

Some highlights for me at the 2011 conference included:
• The delicious food at the early arrivers' party.
• Stephen Booth’s paper on Shakespeare and Audiences.
• Go Dog Go, as devised and performed by Chris Johnston, John Harrell, Jeremy West, Dan Kennedy, Greg Phelps, Miriam Donald, and James Keegan.
• Hearing about the new Indoor Theatre in London from Neil Constable (Heck, meeting Neil Constable).
• Bill Gelber’s ‘ A “Ha” in Shakespeare....”
• Ben Curns sleeping onstage (as directed) in Casey Caldwell’s paper (and then using lightening quick reflexes not to knock over the 100 champagne glasses set behind the curtain as he exited).
• Chris Barrett.
• Joe Ricke and Jemma Levy in a morning session to rival all others.
• George T. Wright and James Keegan’s mutual admiration discussion.
• Finding out “Why are there no blowjob jokes in Shakespeare” from Matt Kozusko.
• Beth Burns and the Hidden Room.
• Stuart Hall’s participation, thanks to Brett Sullivan Santry.
• Natasha Solomon and Dan Burrows acting in Bob Hornback’s Renaissance Clowns paper.
• Seeing our Conference Attendees see John Harrell’s Hamlet.
• Our late night shows (wow).
• William Proctor William’s experiment.
• Seeing ASC actors at every paper session (even the EARLY ones).
• Watching worlds come together in Scott Kaiser’s keynote.
• The bear(s).
• Talking teaching.
• Tiff.
• Colloquies.
• Insights on our space in session X.
• The Banquet.
• Doreen Bechtol in everything she did, but especially Lady M as played by Sarah Siddons (pregnant).
• Hamlet Conversation.


And so, a little over a month past the last day of the conference, I have a little time to reflect. A little time to look around at the people I work with, the place I work for, and thank heavens that, however it came to be, I landed here.

What will you remember?

29 October 2011

Tiffany Stern Keynote

Hi, I'm Julia, I'll be liveblogging Tiffany Stern's Keynote from 10:30-11:15 today.

Tiffany Stern - University College

Dr Stern gave a talk in three parts about fairs in England and their relationship to theater of the period. First, she discussed some of the differences and similarities between Early Modern theater and fairs. Fairs were highly sanctioned, approved by both the local government and the private aristocracy, and they had their own internal legal system including courts, and juries made up of booth-holders. Theaters of the time could only wish to be as legitimized as the fairs. On the other hand, both theaters and fairs were places of entertainment and commerce, and they tended to attract a certain low-life stratus in the form of pickpockets, and prostitutes. The second part of her talk covered several references to fairground activities within Early Modern plays, including trained monkeys who played dead and came back to life if certain names were evoked, (as Romeo is conjured by the name Rosaline), a performer called an "interpreter" who narrated puppet shows (Hamlet could interpret if he could see the puppets dallying), as well as several references to shadow puppets ("life's but a walking shadow, a poor player.."). The third part of her talk went further into Early Modern puppetry, as puppetry was the one form of theater allowed to remain open during the Interregnum in England. Stern also showed how certain of Shakespeare's characters developed a new life as puppets in future hodgepodge works.

28 October 2011

Blackfriars Conference 2011 – Scott Kaiser Keynote

Hello, all! Cass here again to live-blog the Scott Kaiser Keynote Address from 10:30 to 11:15am on Friday, October 28.

Ralph introduces Kaiser by discussing his delight in discovering Kaiser's book, Shakespeare's Wordcraft. He says, though, that by removing the classical Greek and Roman terms for rhetorical devices in an attempt to make the topic more accessible, "you have underestimated the appeal to word-nerds". He half-jokingly suggests, along with his grad students, that he consider reinstating those terms in the second addition. Ralph thanks Kaiser for joining us on behalf of "all the other word-nerds here".

Acting Shakespeare's Wordcraft
Scott Kaiser, Oregon Shakespeare Festival

Kaiser prefaces his speech by introducing his assistant actors, Dan Kennedy and Doreen Bechtol. He'll be talking today about "how to act Shakespeare's figures of rhetoric" by demonstrating how he works with them in rehearsal. Kaiser defends his choice by stating that the classical terms are almost always an impediment for actors -- that his book "is primarily not a scholarly book, but a book for actors and actors-in-training."

Of vital concern to the actor working with rhetoric is "to illuminate the figure to the audience through voice and body." He begins with the "speech measure", using a quote from Stanislavski to explain his meaning: to break down a speech by thought patterns in order to get to the meaning and to make the speech more graceful in form and content. A speech measure, then, is a moment for a choice, "a unit of sense that contains one inhalation, one operative word, one focal point, one image, one action, one moment of human behavior." He then invites Dan and Doreen up to work through some examples.

Dan: "Cassius from bondage will deliver Cassius." Kaiser calls this one parcel of text, bookended with 'Cassius'. Doreen: "I see you what you are; you are too proud." Kaiser calls this two speech measures, pointing out Doreen's inhalation between the two phrases. Dan: "Seems, madam? Nay, it is. I know not seems." Kaiser delineates this as three speech measures, connected by the "seems" on either end, with "is" as a fulcrum in the middle. Doreen: "Come weep with me, past hope, past cure, past help." This Kaiser identifies as four speech measures, but notes that this is not necessarily the only choice -- but that it may "illuminate 'past' in a different way." Dan: "Oh Helen! Goddess, nymph, perfect, divine!" Kaiser points out that this line mostly comes out as one exhalation, and asks Dan to try it again as five speech measures. Kaiser points out that this then differentiates each speech measure, automatically conferring greater emotional variety to the line.

Kaiser then moves on to finding the "operative word" -- the one word in the measure that is key. It can be created through pitch, volume, or duration. Dan: "What lusty trumpet thus doth summon us?" Kaiser asks Dan to pick one word to make the operative; he chooses "trumpet", using volume and pitch to key it. Kaiser has him try again, this time with "summon" -- he helps Dan out by giving him the incipient action, having him imagine the actual trumpet before delivering the line. Kasier points out that he "stacked the deck" against Dan by giving him a line full of schwas -- and that holding that vowel "would make it Transylvanian".

Dan: "One woman is fair; yet I am well; another is wise; yet I am well; another virtuous; yet I am well." Kaiser identifies this as three measures, and says he heard three operative words from Dan's first reading: one, wise, and virtuous. He redirects Dan to make the new word in each phrase the operative: fair, wise, and virtuous. You then hear the operative word "build in a staircase". Kaiser points out where Dan held his breath during the line, rather than inhaling as he could have to break it into 6 measures.

Doreen: "I'll tell you who time ambles withal, who time trots withal, who time gallops withal, who he stands still withal." Four measures, and Kaiser points out the different operative verbs. Doreen used what Kaiser calls "a Ted Wright ladder", with a build of three and then a drop in pitch for the fourth. He has her do it again, this time bringing the "tell" down so that it doesn't overwhelm the "amble".

Kaiser then examines "focal points" -- a visual target, "at which you can inhale, towards which you can ascend your energies". Doreen: "Husband, I cannot pray that thou mayest win. Uncle, I needs must pray that thou mayest lose. Father, I may not wish the fortunes thine. Granddam, I will not wish thy wishes thrive." Kaiser asks Doreen to try it again without breaking into new measures at the commas. The result is "greater drive; it could not bear all those breaks."

Dan: "Put out the light, and then put out the light." The focal point changes between the candle and the sleeping Desdemona. Kaiser states, "It's the movement of the focal point that makes the figure work."

Doreen: "Thy deed, inhuman and unnatural, provokes this deluge, most unnatural." Kaiser says she's working with two focal points, which he calls "panning and scanning" mid-measure. He suggests that each measure should have a single focal point for greatest clarity on the stage. He wants the first part to focus on Richard, the second to focus on the body. "The reason I coach this way is because, if your eyes are darting back and forth," the meaning can be lost, especially for audience members farther form the stage.

Dan: "Boldness be my friend! Arm me, audacity, from head to foot!" Kaiser says that Dan's focal points slipped around. Kaiser points out the figure of personification, that Dan is literally talking to Boldness and Audacity, not to himself -- he asks Dan to choose a focal point for each. Finding a specific point for each brings the emotion forward more clearly and makes the point easier to arrive at for the audience; Kaiser points out, "I didn't tell him what to imagine. I just asked him to structure it in a way that would be clear to the audience."

Kaiser then moves to the "image" -- a complete mental creation, which invokes the imaginative aspect of all five senses. Doreen (as Constance in King John): "
Grief fills the room up of my absent child, / Lies in his bed, walks up and down with me, / Puts on his pretty looks, repeats his words, / Remembers me of all his gracious parts, / Stuffs out his vacant garments with his form; / Then, have I reason to be fond of grief?" Kaiser thinks it communicates more clearly the depth of her despair when she doesn't shift her focal point; he asks her to try it again with one single focal point, letting the pressure build up there. Kaiser explains this as finding a single focal point and adding a new layer to it with each measure. "The inesntiy of that single focal point... is so strongly communicated by a single focal point that you understand what all the men are talking about when they call her crazy."

Next: actions -- played in pursuit of objectives against obstacles. Each measure should have one and only one. Dan: "Fool, of thyself speak well. Fool, do not flatter." Kaiser asks Dan to encourage himself in the first measure, then admonish himself in the second. He further examines the shift, particularly with regard to where the inhalation is positioned and where it comes from -- "from his imagination" rather than from the text.

Doreen: "Sweet, sweet, sweet Nurse, tell me, what says my love?" Kaiser says that Doreen has made this three measures, and suggests that the second measure tends to have the same emotion as the first. He asks her to find three wildly different things to play in the three measures (and comments that this tactic is typical of thirteen-year-old girls).

Kaiser then adds the idea of subtext to the lines, which he calls "the realization." Dan: "I wasted time, and now doth time waste me." Kaiser has Dan break that into two measures, asking Dan to realize in the middle, at the comma, that he's now going to die without having accomplished his goals. "The figure is illuminated by the realization at the comma in the middle of the line," by the reversal of emotions that the active silence causes -- "a moment of human behavior that is atextual."

Doreen: "Seeming, seeming! I will proclaim thee, Angelo; look for't." Kaiser suggests that Doreen realize the depth of Angelo's corruption at the comma between the two "seeming"s. Kaiser points out that the repetition requires a variation in delivery, discussing the reasons why people repeat themselves.

Finally, Kaiser comes to decisions, a different type of subtext. Dan: "She sees not Hermia. Hermia, sleep thou there, and never mayest thou come Lysander near." Kaiser suggests the first focal point be on the audience, and that he then make the decision "to leave Hermia there, by herself, unguarded, in the dark." Dan's callous deliberation makes the decision hysterically funny, and Kaiser suggests that seeing the choice happen is what makes that humorous for the audience.

Doreen: "What if this potion do not work at all? Shall I be married then tomorrow morning? No, no, this shall forbid it." Kaiser points out that Doreen has several focal points operating, talking to herself but also indicating the dagger that she will use to kill herself. He asks her to make a decision between the two "No"s. Kaiser notes that this speech complicates delivery, because it layers the decision on top of multiple actions, moving from measure to measure.

Kaiser wraps up by saying that effective theatre lives in these decisions, "not in when the giant neon apple flies down out of the ceiling."

27 October 2011

Blackfriars Conference 2011 - George T. Wright Keynote Address

Greetings! I'm Charlene V. Smith and it's 10:30 am on Day 2 of the 2011 Blackfriars Conference. George T. Wright from the University of Minnesota is giving the Keynote today, entitled "Climbing Shakespeare's Ladder, and Other Sound Patterns." Wright is well-known among the both the conference attendees and the graduate students at Mary Baldwin due to his seminal work Shakespeare's Metrical Art.

After some announcements from Sarah Enloe, director of Education at the ASC, Dr. Ralph Alan Cohen takes the stage to introduce Wright. Wright is a professor emeritus of English at the University of Minnesota. Besides Shakespeare's Metrical Art, Wright has also written Hearing the Measures: Shakespearean and Other Inflections and Poetical Craft and Authorial Design.  Dr. Ralph says that when the graduate Shakespeare program at MBC began, he really wanted to use Shakespeare's Metrical Art as a classroom textbook. He was worried that some students, less familiar with Chaucer and poetry, might find it difficult. He says he made the mistake of using a different book, but for year two of the program Ralph "switched to the Wright/right book."

Wright begins by noting his growing interest in ladders in Shakespeare's text, and that years ago he noticed too many actors underplaying long verse speeches and rhetoric. They were being cheated of their force, brought down to the prose moments of the play.

Wright grew aware of growing interest amongst British actors and directors in speaking Shakespeare's verse. Wright was interested in how verse was heard by the ear of the audience. These actors and directors were looking for guidance and rules for shared lines, pauses, enjambed versus end stopped lines, etc. Wright cares much more about the weight given to stressed and unstressed lines as they are critical to the emotional intensity of the text.

Wright notes that there are three kinds of people interested in the meter of the verse: Actors, editors, prosodists. The questions each group asks are how shall we speak the lines, how shall we print the lines, and how shall we hear the lines, respectively. Wrights says that editors and actors must print and speak the lines in a way that allows us to read and hear the lines as metrically coherent.

Wright has consulted many texts of Shakespeare's verse and has not found much dealing with the ladder. As an example, he presents an early speech from Julius Caesar, a speech Wright says in a perfect example of a ladder.

And do you not put on your best attire?
And do you not cull out a holiday?
And do you not strew flowers in he way
That comes in triumph over Pompey's blood?
Be gone!
Run to your houses, fall upon your knees
Pray to the gods to intermit the plague
That needs must light on this ingratitude.
(1.1.48-55)

The first four lines step up, and the last three lines step back down the ladder. A ladder is sequences of clauses that keep elaborating on a topic until it's been exhausted and then the actor has to run back down.

After 1593, Shakespeare's line really find their range. Wright says we have the plague to thank, as it caused Shakespeare to write the sonnets. With the sonnets, Shakespeare was training himself to compose verse speech in a larger four line unit. Though many sonnets are end stopped at the end of each line, usually do to the rhyme scheme. The end stopping of the lines halts the rising of the verse. There is an inherent rise and fall in the structure of the sonner. The quatrains build up and then down.

Shakespeare then used more ladders in his blank verse. Wright demonstrates Shakespeare's powerful buildup via ladders with Richard II's "For God's sake, let us sit upon the ground," John of Gaunt's This England, and Henry V's famous St. Crispin Day speeches. Shakespeare had found a new way to be seriously expressive. Why say a thing once, when saying it differently and again and again will make it more memorable?

Wright notes that the performance of these ladders is not always the same, nor is it a continuous rise. The voice likes to back track a little, or down track a little, before it continues to the next level of the speeches. Wright speaks some of Macbeth's speech, "Who can be wise, amazed, temperate and furious, / Loyal and neutral, in a moment?" This speech goes up and down constantly, as if Macbeth doesn't know where he wants to be.

Wright launches into Claudio's speech from Measure for Measure, "Ay, but to die, and go we know not where," a speech Wright calls, "one of the finest of all ladder speeches." This speech goes up for many lines, and then steps down powerfully. The imagery is as over the top as the dramatic structure of the ladder, and Wright suggests that Shakespeare intended that.

Wright notes that every actor will not perform ladders the same way, but that the device should be recognized as respecting it creates a powerful effect. Shakespeare was an extraordinary writer but also an extraordinary listener.

Wright loves the increasing attention given in recent years to the performance of verse, but the more he reads about it the more questions he has. Metrical variations add texture to Shakespeare's verse. Readers, editors, and voice professionals need to note these variations. Not just the normal variations such as trochees, but the rarer ones such as hexameter, broken-back lines, and epic caesuras, should be considered. Shakespeare uses these irregularities more than the other Elizabethan and Jacobean dramatists, and we should wonder why.

Wright then takes a few questions from the audience. One person asks about Wright's suggestions that we have some reservations when we hear a ladder, and wonders if that is connected to a feeling that the ladder is calculated. Wright likes the idea and the suggestions it gives for performance. Another scholar asks about evangelism and whether Wright thinks Shakespeare could have picked up some of the ladder technique from church. Wright thinks it is completely possible and beautifully quotes a poem of John Donne. Mary Baldwin professor Matt Davies mentions that the sonnets were metrically regular, and that so were the examples, there weren't a lot of inverted feet in them, which might cause a trip in the ladder.  He asks whether regularity is essential to building a ladder. Other audience members respond to this idea and ASC actor James Keegan says he notes that sort of thing a lot in Tamburlaine. Keegan then notes that he feels contemporary actors are afraid of pitch, of singing the pitch, and has anxiety about it. Wright agrees, and says that they are afraid of going of the top. But Wright says he'd like to hear actors going over the top a bit more and notes that you can find fine examples of this, nodding to Keegan's fine performance as Prospero in The Tempest the night before.

26 October 2011

Blackfriars Conference 2011 – Welcome and Stephen Booth Keynote

Greetings to all -- The 6th Blackfriars Conference has officially begun! A team of ASC employees and MBC MLitt/MFA graduate students will be live-blogging throughout the week, so that those of you who couldn't be here to join us can still get a little taste of the scholarship and other exciting events. Our livebloggers for the week are: Christina Sayer Grey, the ASC's Marketing Associate, graduate students Charlene Smith, Julia Nelson, and Deborah Streusand, and me, Cass Morris, the ASC's Academic Resources Manager.

9:45 am - Welcome Address

The welcome opens with Ralph Alan Cohen introducing Amy Wratchford, the ASC's managing director, Paul Menzer, director of the MLitt/MFA graduate program, Dean Catharine O'Connell from Mary Baldwin College, Steven Owen, Staunton City Manager, and ASC Director of Education Sarah Enloe.

Sarah and Ralph give everyone an overview of their packet materials, both those essentials of the conference, such as maps, nametags, schedules, and directories, and the fun bits: the Truancy Award (given to the person who spends more time exploring Staunton than actually attending conference events) and the swag, including a thermos and water bottle (so that the conference can "go green" and not offer plastic or styrafoam cups for water and coffee).

Ralph comments about the special late-night shows, 11pm performances of original (but Shakespeare-related) works. Ralph then warns everyone about the bear. It's a bit infamous at our conference that, if your paper runs over time, you will have to exit, pursued by a bear. A thunder sheet gives presenters a 2-minute warning, and Sarah lets the bear out of the cage so that everyone can see what they'll be baiting if they go on for too long.

Ralph calls attention to a few changes and additions to the program. In celebration of our partnership with Washington and Lee, who are now hosting the ASC archives, we will be holding a champagne reception at 4:45pm, immediately following the last paper session.

Farah Karim-Cooper and Neil Constable from Shakespeare's Globe in London then take the stage to discuss their plans to build a new indoor theatre in London. Farah explains the history of the research behind their plans -- that the architectural designs were originally thought to be created by Inigo Jones in 1616, but that later research revealed them to be a later creation. As a result, the Globe has decided to construct an archetype of Jacobean theatres, rather than re-creating one specific building. Neil then walks the audience through a short Powerpoint presentation which conveys the visual plans for the indoor theatre. He discusses the planned timeline for project completion, estimating that by the fall of 2013, the indoor theatre will be open and in use, allowing the Globe to perform 52 weeks a year -- which will make the Globe and the American Shakespeare Center the only two Shakespeare theatres in the world who run shows continuously.

Ralph thanks everyone at the Globe for their support not only for the Blackfriars Playhouse but for their ongoing support of our goals to build Globe II, a re-creation of the 1614 Globe.

Ralph then moves into introducing Stephen Booth, Professor emeritus of English literature at the University of California at Berkeley. Booth is the author of On the Value of Hamlet; Shakespeare's Sonnets, Edited with Analytic Commentary; King Lear, Macbeth, Indefinition, and Tragedy, and Precious Nonsense: The Gettysburg Address, Ben Jonson's Epitaphs on His Children, and Twelfth Night. Ralph shares some anecdotes about working with Stephen over the years, then introduces him by saying, "Today Stephen is going to share with us some things about audience that he already knows and that we have never thought about."

10:30am - Stephen Booth Keynote: "Shakespeare vs the Audience", or, "The Audience as Lady Anne"

"You will notice, with pleasure, how briefly the previous speakers have spoken. That is all over." Stephen then absconds with two cushions from the gallant stools, to further elevate his reading podium. Booth claims that we should look at Richard III as the greatest author analog in Shakespeare, relating Shakespeare's joy in "rhetoric over circumstance" to Richard III's delight in the rhetorical power to woo Lady Anne. He then moves on to the odd abortive ending of Love's Labour's Lost and to The Tempest, "Shakespeare's greatest success in leading the audience to increasingly improbably responses". Prospero, he says, is a failure both as a character ("he bores us") and as a leader, who he characterizes as "casually unjust". Booth argues that audiences come away with an impression of Prospero that reflects his final generosity, not his moment-to-moment cruelties. Similarly, audiences at the end of Romeo and Juliet feel they have seen the play the prologue promised, when the play itself undercuts much of the outline. The Winter's Tale he categorizes as another instance of inappropriate responses to circumstances, with giant logic holes that the audience blithely ignores, and with characters such as Autolycus, "who seems to be there just to see if the play can get away with it".

Not all of Shakespeare's plays, however, achieve such a success of theatre over context, nor are they always consistent within a play. Booth relates Shakespeare's overconfidence with language again to Richard III, whose triumph in his second wooing scene is less justified than his first. He then provides a list of plays where the contextual misalignments tempt the audience to dismiss or question circumstances: Richard III ends with Henry of Richmond, Macbeth with the bloodless Malcolm. In Much Ado about Nothing, "the unnecessary detail that asks audience's minds to accommodate the presence of two people in Hero's window who have no business in Hero's bedchamber" and the subsequent request that they believe this would cause Claudio to believe Hero unfaithful, Booth says strains credulity. He moves next to the Chorus in Henry V, who asserts a confidence in the King that the play itself undercuts. In Hamlet, audiences agree with the Ghost for chastising Hamlet's delay, even though both Ghost and audience know that Polonius's corpse is right there and that the Ghost's pointed language imitates the weapon Hamlet used. In Macbeth, audiences "ignore the comic klutz that Macbeth is" when his superstitions lead him to unnecessary murders (when warned against Banquo's children, he kills Macduff's). In King Lear, the "wicked" sisters Goneril and Regan give voice to what the audience must think about a father and a king overconfident in his own omnipotence, yet forty minutes later, the audience believes them as pure and entirely sympathetic victims. "Shakespeare manipulates audiences into unlikely acquiescence." Julius Caesar makes the relation very plain through its association of the audience with the plebeian mob.

Booth warns that he may be leaving us with the impression Shakespeare felt the same contempt for audiences that Richard III felt for Lady Anne and Lady Elizabeth. He claims that he had no intention of giving us that impression when he began the paper, but now feels sure that he has, and asks us to "consider the evidence."

The address ends early enough that we can open for questions. One question asks if the audiences might be seen to derive pleasure from being insulted by Shakespeare, as Groucho Marx became famous and adored for insulting audiences. Booth responds that he thinks the critical importance is that intelligent audiences like being insulted if they know they're being insulted, whereas Shakespeare, he believes, "doesn't offer a smirk" of knowledge at them. Another question asks if Booth believes Shakespeare gets us to consent to his treatment; Booth agrees, yes, he does. Another scholar comments that "we're not really rationalists" when we're in the audience. She brings up Measure for Measure, where the Duke manipulates Isabella, claiming that he'll offer her comforts when he does nothing of the kind. She asks, "Where is the emotion?" and wonders if it's up to the actors either to connect with the audience or to make them feel the disconnect.